Allstate vs. state farm homeowners insurance review

Regarding home insurance in the United States, two of the most prominent players are State Farm and Allstate. Both companies boast solid financial ratings and a wide range of policy options, making them comparable. However, significant differences in deductibles and other factors can influence which of these insurance giants is the better choice for your home coverage. Let’s delve deeper to find out more.

Allstate vs. state farm homeowners insurance review
Allstate vs. state farm homeowners insurance review

State Farm VS Allstate

In our 2023 standings, State Farm and Allstate ranked 2nd and 3rd, respectively. Both options can be solid choices for most homeowners, but each has benefits and drawbacks, which may affect your decision.

Coverage Options

Although both companies offer standard coverages found in most homeowners’ insurance policies, they do differ in the additional options they provide:

State Farm Coverage:

  1. Building Code Coverage: Pays for rebuilding or repairing your property following current building codes.
  2. Valuable Goods Coverage: Offers options for holding water, valuable goods, and building codes.
  3. Service Line Coverage: Provides coverage for damage to service lines or systems in your home.

Allstate Coverage:

  1. Garden and Yard Coverage: Allstate covers your yard and garden, plus offers supplemental insurance for specialty personal belongings like musical instruments and sporting goods.

Savings and Discounts: State Farm and Allstate’s Offers

Each company has unique savings and discounts to entice customers:


State Farm Savings:

  1. Lower Rates for New/Renovated Homes: State Farm provides lower rates for newly constructed or renovated homes.
  2. Early Shopping Discount: Customers who shop for insurance early can benefit from additional savings.
  3. Customer Loyalty Incentive: State Farm rewards its loyal customers with special discounts.

Allstate Savings:

  1. Green Repayment Coverage: Allstate’s basic policy includes green repayment coverage to bring your home back to an environmentally friendly level after a loss.
  2. Homeowner Policy Alternatives: Allstate offers alternatives to raising coverage limits for personal possessions like musical instruments, sporting goods, or commercial property.

Specific Coverage Questions

Let’s address some common coverage-related queries about both insurers:

  • Mold Removal or Damage:

Both State Farm and Allstate may cover mold damage if it resulted from a burst pipe or sudden problem reported immediately. However, gradual mold development due to poor maintenance might not be covered.

  • Roof Leaks:

Roof leaks are covered by both companies as part of the basic policy, except for leaks caused by poor maintenance, which are not covered.

  • Termite Damage:

Neither State Farm nor Allstate typically covers termite damage in their standard homeowners’ insurance policies. This is commonly considered avoidable with regular grooming.

  • Water Damage:

Both insurers cover unexpected water damage, such as a broken pipe or torn washer line. However, damage from a broken sump pump or drain clog is often deemed maintenance-related and not covered. Flood damage requires a separate policy and is omitted.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Highlights

Allstate, ranked 3rd in our 2023 Best Home Insurance Companies ranking, stands out with several distinctive features:

  1. More Discounts: Allstate offers more discounts than other insurance companies, making it an attractive option for cost-conscious customers.
  2. Green Improvement Compensation: Allstate’s basic policy includes green improvement compensation to cover additional expenses when replacing protected items with more energy-efficient versions.
  3. Special Coverage for Personal Possessions: Allstate provides supplemental insurance for specialty personal belongings like musical instruments and sporting goods.

State Farm Homeowners Insurance Highlights

State Farm, holding the 2nd spot in our ranking, has its own set of advantages:

  1. Expansive Agent Network: State Farm boasts an extensive agent network covering all 50 states and the District of Columbia, ensuring easy access for customers.
  2. Options for Coverage Expansion: State Farm offers various opportunities to expand and modify policies, including coverage for home systems and service lines.
  3. Affordable Pricing: State Farm’s monthly premium for virtual property starts at just $88.83, making it a reasonable choice for homeowners.


In conclusion, State Farm and Allstate are reputable home insurance providers with distinct strengths and offerings. To determine which one suits you better, carefully consider your coverage needs, budget, and any unique requirements you may have. Conduct a detailed comparison and contact representatives for further information. A well-informed decision will protect your home adequately under the right insurance policy.


Remember, insurance needs may vary, so choose wisely!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like